Being a good sport on voting rights - Mullins
THE vexed issue of voting rights is one of the most contentious and, often, business progress-limiting concerns for sports organisations.
Mullins Lawyers partner John Mullins said it was becoming an increasingly tricky area and recommended sports organisations focus on adjusting constitutions ahead of problems that may emerge because outdated voting systems may impinge on sports development.
“There are as many different structures, methods and formulas to determine members’ voting rights as you can imagine,” Mr Mullins said. “Indeed the variables are only limited by your imagination.
“In some organisations individual members have voting rights and in other organisations the voting rights belong to other legal structures, regions or clubs within the organisation.
“Probably the issue that gets most focus is the right to appoint a proxy. There is a good deal of confusion as to whether proxies are lawful, unlawful, mandatory or optional,” he said.
“The simple fact is that for a company limited by guarantee proxies are mandatory. The Corporations Act proxy rule is not a replaceable rule and for companies limited by guarantee the constitution should provide for proxy voting.”
Mr Mullins said for incorporated associations under the Associations Incorporation Act, whether there is a right to proxies or not depends on what is written in the constitution.
“If the constitution says there are proxies, then there are,” he said. “If the constitution says there are not proxies, then there are no proxies.
“There is a good deal of confusion as to whether proxies are lawful, unlawful, mandatory or optional.”
Where this becomes even more murky is in Section 47 of the Associations Incorporation Act which says: “If a matter is not provided for under an incorporated association’s own rules but the matter is provided for under a provision of the model rules, the association’s own rules are taken to include the additional provision.”
Mr Mullins said in his experience it was possible to provide in a constitution that Section 47 does not apply.
“If the constitution is silent on proxies and you have not specifically excluded the application of Section 47 then pursuant to Clause 40 of the Model Rules, proxies are permitted in your association,” Mr Mullins said. “We see numerous examples in companies limited by guarantee where proxies are prohibited and other examples of where incorporated associations who should, by virtue of the application of the Model Rules above, allow proxies but don’t.”
Mr Mullins suggested sports bodies seek legal advice well ahead of time on how their constitutions may need to be reconfigured to achieve modern objectives.